Heavy Metal Affliction - Turn 10's Dan Greenawalt on APEX: The Making of the Hypercar
If you missed the chance to see “APEX: The Making of the Hypercar” last Thursday, or weren’t at the theatrical screening that took place last night in New York, don’t worry, it will be re-played on NBCSN through June near the network’s Formula One coverage.
Turn 10 creative director Dan Greenawalt is one of the many industry and car culture voices that speak to the influence that the car’s featured in this film have on our lives. This week we have some great insight from Greenawalt in today’s edition of HMA. As the film’s producer J.F. Musial said in last week’s story, “I look at Dan as having a better understanding at what car enthusiasts want, probably more than some board members within the industry from some top level manufacturers have.”
Heavy Metal Affliction: As a contributor to “APEX: The Making of the Hypercar,” what perspective did you offer?
Dan Greenawalt: I think there are two axes that are really interesting about the story of “APEX.” One is the obvious one that cars have evolved and the idea of a supercar has evolved into a “hypercar” or perhaps even a “mega-car”. If you were to believe [Christian von] Koenigsegg, that is what has happened over the last ten or twenty years; that we have seen the [Porsche] 959 and the [Ferrari] F40 turn into these crazy cars.
The other axis is change in media. So we had kind of old world media, and I don’t mean that in a bad way at all, in Dan Neil. Dan Neil’s perspective is amazing but, he is kind of Wall Street Journal, he is long form media, he’s a really good journalist. But, we have seen journalism give way to this YouTube generation and player-created things. You have Chris Harris who is also kind of a journalist, he’s kind of an entertainer, kind of a celebrity, but he is in that YouTube generation where he is doing car reviews. But, now we are in this very different age moving on to even games where we have content creators who actually use our game as the medium. So, I think there is a different continuum over the last twenty years of media like the Wall Street Journal giving way to gamers that are able to live virtual lives and create virtual experiences using games like Forza.
So, the perspective I was giving was similar to what Dan Neil has seen of the last twenty years, similar to what Chris Harris has seen over the last twenty years but, for me, it’s from the game perspective.
HMA: What was it like to be a part of it?
DG: Mic work was really easy. J.F. came in to talk and ask questions, and I’ve known J.F. for a number of years, so there is instant comfort there in talking to him about cars. Of course he is a dyed-in-the-wool car guy so, we could have a conversation for days. It was just a question of when they turned on the recorder.
We actually recorded for quite a while, so I had no idea how my part was going to play into the larger narrative. I was being asked about mega-trends and minor trends and technology and design cues and personalities. I went on the record on a lot of different topics that are really purely opinion on my part. Then there were a couple areas that were really technical. How [Turn 10] builds these cars, what it means to simulate them and how they are pushing boundaries. So, I didn’t know how I was going to be integrated in there. But, it was cool to see because I think the different voices provided really different perspectives.
Chris and Dan and myself as well were looking at Christian von Koenigsegg and Horatio Pagani and these other [automotive] stalwarts. In many ways they were the sources and we were kind of on the outside, providing color and interesting information.
HMA: What do you think makes Koenigsegg so unique? Is it Christian von Koenigsegg, the cars themselves? What?
DG: The thing I really love about Koenigsegg and all of these hypercars is the chances the companies are able to take but, also the way the culture of the company and the culture of the parent organization is able to influence the design.
When you look at the big three – the 918, La Ferrari, and the P1 – these are big companies. They are doing the same thing but they are all doing it very differently, which is amazing.
Then, you look at the boutiques; it’s not clear where their cultural standings are. What I love about Koenigsegg, and I think it has to do with him in particular, is that he designs these cars that have this really singular vision. When you look at the One:1, and he’s like, “Look I want kilowatt to kilogram, one-to-one.” It’s just like this lightning bolt that goes through the design.
Even when you look at the Regera, [Koenigsegg said] “I want to be looking at electric but, I want to be looking at it in a new way.” It’s really cool and that’s unique. It’s interesting to look at Ferrari, and Porsche, and Lamborghini against each other but, they are bigger companies. When you get to these boutiques, it’s really just Pagani and Koenigsegg there that have this kind of vision. Koenigsegg is on the technical side and Pagani is on the artistic side.
I love that it wasn’t clear going in to APEX that’s what the story was going to be about. It was kind of about the dawn of the hypercar all up but, I love that it went in and had this vignette that was really opposing Pagani versus Koenigsegg as different visions for where the hypercar is going.
HMA: Tell me the first word that comes into your mind for each one of these cars: LaFerrari?
DG: Flamboyant
HMA: McLaren P1
DG: Space-age
HMA: Porsche 918
DG: Subtle
HMA: Koenigsegg One:1
DG: Focused
HMA: Pagani Huayra
DG: Art
HMA: Ferrari F40
DG: Raw
HMA: Could you pick a favorite from this batch of cars?
DG: I think that if I were rich enough to have a Frank Lloyd Wright house overlooking something that was pure art, I think having a Pagani in your living room, just kind of opened up. That’s really something amazing. I don’t care if I ever drove it, just seeing it would be enough.
HMA: How important is it for Forza Motorsport to offer driving experiences in the cars featured in the movie? How does this compare to offering the driving experience in more everyman cars?
DG: We talk about the five cars that speak to you in Forza a lot. When you think about the first car that really got you on the path, maybe it’s your first car, the first car you owned, maybe it’s the car your uncle worked on. Then, there is the first car you had to stress about buying, either it was more expensive and you stretched for it, that first proof point where you [were] saying, “I’m a car guy.”
You then start getting into cars that are race based and they speak to people because they are incredibly fast maybe iconic, like an exotic GT car. Maybe this is the Countach poster on your wall. If you’re younger and you have a phone, maybe it’s the car on the lock screen of your phone, that’s maybe the new car poster of today’s generation.
Then you get into these cars that [make you ask] what the hell is going on physics-wise. They just bend your brain, and those experiences strangely enough are easier for us in many ways to capture in simulation because the things they have to come up with to build all these crazy assists that make it possible to drive a 1,000-horsepower car means they have to know things about what is going on in the real world at a frequency that is very difficult. In a sense it’s more machine learning or they have to have really advanced training that is also working on sensors in the car that are perceiving the world in ways the car can’t. The car really needs to know what is the slip angle of the tire right now. In our game we know that data at any time of the day.
HMA: Each of these hypercar manufacturers delivers a nuanced and deliberate approach to how their cars are perceived and driven. How does Turn 10 translate that to how they feel in game?
DG: I think we impose a lot of that as players and drivers and connoisseurs of cars. A lot of it comes purely out of the physics, just pure math, then we impose on that to make “2 +2 = 5.” Where we are looking at the beautiful lines of the LaFerrari and it’s driving the way the physics say and when we add these two together, we say “passion.”
We throw something on top of it. Of course the physics make them drive differently because they have different architecture going on and they have different ways that they make downforce and they bleed off downforce, they don’t want to make too much. How they attain a top speed, whether it’s limited electronically, or limited by aerodynamics, or some combination of the two. There a lot of little nuances that change how it gets fast and how fast it gets. I think, as drivers, we impose or we project a lot on to these cars that is not really physically-based.
The thing that is hard to capture is the fear these cars can generate, because they are just so fast you can feel the car is capable of much more than your reaction time.
HMA: How does Forza Motorsport continue to evolve as a brand that comes to mind when car lovers think of the most exciting and exotic cars on the planet?
DG: First off, when you watch APEX, there are very few franchises that allow you to get that experience. We have got most of those cars. We have all the cars featured there in the hypercar category. So getting to have that virtual test, what would it mean to have a LaFerrari versus a P1 versus a 918? I’m not aware of another game that allows you to get that experience.
So the easy answer is, we do it, we’ve got these cars. I think the more interesting answer, with regard to how we stay on the cutting edge, has to do with us continuing the dialogue with car culture. Car culture is changing. Yes, hypercars are getting faster, news media is going from Wall Street Journal to Jalopnik. All of that is being outdated by Twitch and YouTube and user-created streams.
So, we are part of that discussion, and the reason we are able to evolve along with it is because we are part of it. Because we were born in digital media, because we were born in games we have a bit of an advantage over some of the older forms of media generally.
HMA: What is your favorite part of the film?
DG: The thing that struck me most about the movie was the cinematography all-up. I really like the way it was shot. It was beautiful seeing Chris Harris drift but what I think I liked the most, kind of cerebrally, was the juxtaposition of the head and the heart. There’s Dan Neil, who is very analytical and intelligent with tremendous context, and Chris Harris, who has just as much context and he’s just as deep in car culture but it’s all gut. So there is this head side and a gut side, and having those two voices come in and go left, right, left, right, I like that.
If you missed last week’s debut of “APEX: The Making of the Hypercar” last week on NBCSN, the film will replay another nine times during the 2016 Formula One season between now and June.
As of March 29 the film will be available for download through iTunes, Google Play, Amazon.com and Vimeo.
Back to the news